Category: Pubs
Carbrook Hall
As you are probably aware, as a pub, the ACV-rated, Carbrook Hall closed in March 2017 and over two years later reopened as ‘Starbucks Carbrook Hall.’ Just before Christmas, I finally visited. The Jacobean wood panelling in the ‘Old Oak Room’ has been retained and is in good condition. However, the ceiling has received a heavy dose of white paint. On my previous visit, in April 2019 while renovations were taking place, the ceiling was exhibiting the distinctive colourful design which had been in place for years.
This heavy use of white paint is the heritage equivalent of taking white paint to the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel (1471/81). From 1508/12, Michelangelo painted the Renaissance frescoes on the ceiling. They remain to this day. The same should have happened to the paintwork on the ceiling of the Old Oak Room.
Suffice to say, that was my last ever visit to a Starbucks.
Dave Pickersgill
The Plough, Sandygate
As previously stated, we believe that the Plough should be functioning as a Community pub, with the added attraction of its key place in the history of world football. A small internal museum would not be inappropriate. However, the Plough continues to be under threat.
The planning saga commenced when the previous owners, Enterprise Inns (Ei), decided to deliberately run-down their historically important asset before closure in 2015. Since then, there has been no serious maintenance work. Ei and the subsequent owners, Spacepad Construction Ltd., have left the pub to rot. Planning law places responsibility for the condition of the site with the current owner. By law, the building should have been maintained in a fit and proper condition for its current permitted use as a public house.
The site has deteriorated to such an extent that some local residents claim it is an ‘eyesore.’ These concerns are currently the subject of a Planning Enforcement enquiry regarding the unauthorised use of the site as a waste disposal facility and a storage site for unregistered vehicles. An Enforcement Notice has been recommended. Sheffield CC should issue a requirement for the building, and site, to be reinstated to the condition it was in at the time of purchase from Ei. At that point, an independent report, commissioned by the Plough Community Benefit Society Ltd., demonstrated that, in order for the pub to reopen, no major building work was required and that internal refitting costs were manageable within a realistic business plan. If the owners fail to reinstate the property, the Council should exercise its power to compulsorily purchase in order to avoid further deterioration.
The additional material recently submitted to the planning application by the applicant is essentially a re-mix of previously submitted documents, including correspondence concerning the marketing of the Plough and the exorbitant, and unrealistic, rental valuation of £50,000 per annum. The additional material does not demonstrate continuous marketing of the Plough at a realistic valuation as required by widely agreed criteria such as CAMRA’s Viability Test.
The recent planning history of a site is also a relevant consideration in planning decisions. In 2017, the local authority rejected Sainsbury’s application for change of use based on the Plough’s listing as an ACV and it accepted that there were no alternative community facilities within a reasonable distance. In 2018, following the sale of the Plough, the local authority re-listed the pub as an ACV. As there have been no material changes in the reasons why the Plough was listed as an ACV, this should remain an overriding consideration in any decision.
The closing date for comments regarding the latest planning application is 28th.January 2020: www.sheffield.gov.uk/planning reference: 19/02130/FULThe pub is adjacent to the ground of Hallam FC (the 2nd.oldest football club in the world). Hallam occupy Sandygate, the oldest football ground in the world, the site of the first football game (Hallam v Sheffield FC) as recognised by FIFA. The Plough should be allowed to return as both a community pub and a key player in the developing Sheffield Football History experience.
Dave Pickersgill, Pub Heritage Officer
“Heart of the City 2” and the Sportsman
Inn Brief
A new pub has opened in Castleton. The Swiss House bar on How Lane is part of a family run bed and breakfast accommodation and open to the public, serving up to four real ales. (Photo Robin Gee).
The former Palm Tree at Walkley has reopened as the Raven under the same ownership as Loxley Brewery and the Wisewood Inn, following a thorough refurbishment. Six cask beers are available, a mix of Loxley and guest beers.
The Shepley Spitfire at Totley Rise has reopened following refurbishment.
If you enjoyed visiting the Millowners Arms at Kelham Island Museum during our beer festival, the good news is it is now open full time as a proper pub! It features 6 real ales on handpump along with various keg beers and canned craft beers -plus of course wines, spirits and soft drinks.
Bar Stewards on Gibraltar Street has reopened following a refurbishment which has added a second toilet and relocated the bar.
The Wharncliffe Arms reopened as a Bradfield Brewery pub on 21 November.
The Dove & Rainbow is hosting a meet the brewer event with Laine Brew Company on 27 November at 6:30pm.
The Ale Club on Ecclesall Road celebrated their 2nd birthday and Hop Hideout, now in Kommune food hall on Angel Street, celebrated their 6th birthday over the weekend of 16 November. Hop Hideout are also extending their weekend opening hours for the duration of the Christmas shopping period.
The Sheffield Tap celebrates its 10th birthday on 28 November from 5pm with some classic beers as well as a new one brewed to celebrate ten years, there will also be cake!
Walkley Beer Company celebrate their 5th birthday on 29 November and the beer line up will include the launch of a collaboration brew with Neepsend.
The Devonshire Cat‘s Black Friday event this year is on 29 November, here it isn’t people at a shopping mall getting stampeded in the rush for discounted goods, it is a celebration of dark beer styles with some rather interesting beers to try!
Peddler Market December event is on Friday 6 (5pm-11pm) and Saturday 7 (2pm-11pm) with the usual format of street food vendors, craft beer and other drinks, makers stalls and music inside and out the warehouse at 92 Burton Road. The guest brewery featuring on the tap wall this month is Gun Brewery.
A small new bar called Berlin Bar has opened in Crookesmoor, no real ale though.
The former Pa’s Bar & Bistro has now reopened as Bar Kelham, serving food and drink starting with breakfast at 9am. No real ale however. CAMRA pub heritage update
After a lengthy absence, the CAMRA national Pub Heritage website is now back on line in a much improved format.
This is the definitive guide to the nation’s most important historic pub interiors. Since the 1960s few pubs have escaped major changes but this website helps you seek out the best remaining historic examples.
This list has been compiled by CAMRA’s Pub Heritage Group and is the product of over thirty years of careful research. It identifies pubs with intact traditional interiors or which have features and rooms of national importance. They range from simple unaltered village pubs to glorious late-Victorian extravaganzas.
In addition, the third edition of the Sheffield Pub Heritage book is now available as a free download. This has expanded to 113 pages and includes new entries and almost 100 new images.
Pub sales and developments
Bulls Head, Foolow
The Bulls Head received ACV (Asset of Community Value) status in August 2015. Three years later, the owner wishes to ‘enter into a relevant disposal.’ In other words, they intend to sell the site. As the pub has ACV status, there was an initial six week moratorium during which community interest groups could wish to signal their wish to be treated as a potential bidder. This period ended on the 31st.October. As there has been no community interest, the owner is now free to sell the pub to any potential bidder. A change of use will require planning permission.
Queen’s Hotel, Scotland Street
Sheffield City Council have received a request for an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) for the site of the Queen’s Hotel from a local company, DLP Planning. Their aim is to demolish the pub and replace it by an eleven storey building with ground floor retail/commercial uses and 230 apartments. This is the first stage in the planning process. The EIS should ascertain if the proposed development is likely to have significant effects on the environment. Full detail is available from SCC: https://tinyurl.com/y4zgkeol This building dates from 1791 when it opened as Queens Inn. It was rebuilt in 1928 and closed in April 1997. The slowly decaying remains boast some distinctive Wards sign work, similar to that at Shakespeare’s.
Former Old Bulls Head, Little Hucklow Renovation work has started on the Old Bull’s Head in Little Hucklow, the building having been unused for well over a decade. This will involve alterations to the pub building, including the addition of a glazed ‘seed room’ extension, the addition of an external stone stair, an extension to the south-west corner, removal of the porch, alterations to openings, and internal layout changes. In addition, the car park will be altered to accommodate a new building which includes six letting rooms. The pub was a regular Good Beer Guide entry in the 1970’s and 80’s when it sold a fine pint of Buxton-brewed Winkle Saxon Cross Bitter (3.8%). It later sold Wards Bitter. The Old Bulls Head has historical interest dating back to the 12th.Century with claims to be the 5th.oldest pub in England. Little Hucklow was once the scene of much mining activity, with considerable remains of old shafts, gravel hillocks and rakes still surrounding the village. The Bull’s Head pub contained a collection of mining relics. In addition, the handpumps had Shakespearean characters carved in wood. We look forward to them returning to use! More detail is available in the planning report https://tinyurl.com/toxepxq Dave PickersgillHeeley & Broadfield triangle
, Gleadless Road
Previously a failed, closed and boarded up Marstons pub, James Birkett bought the pub in 2000 and transformed it. Two rooms, both clean and simple, good range of real ales and continentel beers at reasonable prices, knowledgable staff and an outdoor drinking area. There have been few substantial changes to the winning formula in the last 19 years, the most notable is that the house beers are now from Neepsend Brewery, which is owned by the same people.
Get there: buses 10/10a/20/24/25/43/44/X17
Brothers Arms, Well Road
Previously known as the Olde Shakespeare, this pub was taken over by a member of the Everley Pregnant Brothers Ukelele Parody band who’s day job is a brewery rep! Inside the pub has a traditional layout with cosy corners and a dart board, there is a great choice of beers at fair prices and basic bar snacks are available. Outside the pubs hillside situation means the extensive beer garden offers views over the City.
Get there: buses 10/10a/20/24/25/43/44/X17
White Lion, London Road
One of Sheffield’s Heritage pubs that still has a corridor and multiple small rooms as well as the bigger open plan rooms towards the back. The pub is also known for having live music most evenings, pretty much the only exception being when it is quiz night! The bar features around 6 cask ales on handpump.
Get there: buses 10/10a/20/24/25/43/44/X17
Pour, London Road
Craft beer and pizza bar. Almost all food and drink served here is vegan. No cask beer, it is possible that real ale in a keykeg may appear from time to time.
Get there: buses 10/10a/20/24/25/43/44/X17
Crown Inn, Albert Road
Traditional and comfortable two room pub with a great beer garden. A range of cask ales are available, mainly from the better known breweries. Food service is a “Pieminister” franchise.
Get there: buses 10/10a/20/24/25/43/44/X17
Tramshed, Chesterfield Road
Small neighbourhood bar with craft beer (no cask) and attached dining room.
Get there: buses 20/24/25/43/44
Hardy Pick, Broadfield Close
Part of Greene King’s Hungry Horse chain with the associated food menu, family friendly, feel of a motorway service station, range of cask beers from Greene King plus a couple of guests.
Broadfield, Abbeydale Road
Pub & Restaurant owned by True North with large patio area at the rear. Always an interesting selection of real ales and other craft beers plus cocktails etc.
Get there: buses 10/10a/75/76/86/97/98
Picture House Social, Abbeydale Road
Located underneath the old Picture House, it consists of a lounge bar, pizza diner, games room and music venue. 2 or 3 real ales normally available along with a few other craft options. There is also an outdoor drinking area accessed via steps from the diner.
Get there: buses 75/76/86/97/98
Two Thirds Beer Company, Abbeydale Road
A neighbourhood craft beer bar with 16 lines of varied cask ales & keg beer, and a bottle bar. Their slogan is “Don’t drink shit beer”. Sounds reasonable to me! Inn Brief
Two Thirds Beer Co
Launching in November 2019, Two Thirds Beer Co. plan to open a new and exciting, neighbourhood craft beer bar in Sheffield; focused primarily on serving high-quality craft beers in smaller than usual two-thirds measures. Founded by three beer-loving enthusiasts, Thirds Beer Co have taken over the old ‘Steel City Cakes’ vegan bake house unit on the up-and-coming bohemian stretch of Abbeydale Road, which is already home to the likes of The Broadfield, Picture House Social, Barrowboy, and Dead Donkey.
The bar will boast a range of over 15 different rotating keg and cask offerings from local breweries and beyond, a serve yourself craft beer fridge, placing a focus on high quality service. Two Thirds Beer Co. hope to be the answer to a market that whilst rapidly growing, is still in its developmental stages in this part of Sheffield, and as passionate craft beer enthusiasts, are excited to share their love and expertise allowing customers the opportunity to discover a wide array of wonderful new drinks from across the continent and beyond. Head to www.twothirdsbeer.co to find out more!